Idea Ripper // ArchiveCards: 1555 [Live] | Updated: 2026-10-14
Card #c1177IR // #c1177Synthesis

"John Hunter used to remark that the art of surgery would not advance until professional men had the courage to publish their failures as well as their successes." "Watt the engineer said, of all things most wanted in mechanical engineering was a history of failures: 'We want,' he said, 'a book of blots.'" "I thank God I was not made a dexterous manipulator, for the most important of my discoveries have been suggested to me by failures."

— In our words · Source: Self-Help (Samuel Smiles)

[Use when]

Your team writes up wins and quietly forgets what didn't work.

[Why it matters]

John Hunter wanted surgeons to publish failures as well as successes, and Watt asked for "a book of blots." Davy said his most important discoveries came from failures.

More from Self-Help

#c1163"He began by breaking three dozen new earthen pots, the pieces of which he covered with different materials which he had compounded, and…Each full test of an idea is expensive and you are testing one variable at a time. #c1164"he noticed that a certain earth containing silica, which was black before calcination, became white after exposure to the heat of a…You keep seeing a small anomaly in your materials and haven't asked what it would let you make. #c1165"He aimed throughout at the highest excellence, declaring his determination 'to give over manufacturing any article, whatsoever it might…Margins are squeezed and the easy fix is a cheaper version under the same name.

Same situation, different book

#c1561The Canon: Sensory Infallibility, Preconceptions, and "Waiting"Use when diagnosing why a high-stakes analysis, intelligence assessment, or debugging effort went wrong…From Lives of Eminent Philosophers #c1551The Tripartite Organism: Logic as Bone, Physics as Flesh, Ethics as SoulDesigning a curriculum, worldbuilding a belief system, or diagnosing why a team's rigorous process (Logic) is…From Lives of Eminent Philosophers #c1545The Cosmic Vortex and the Planetary MembraneUse when designing self-organizing markets, talent incubators, or creative communities where high-collision…From Lives of Eminent Philosophers #c1536Thales's Ensouled Matter and Cosmological SuperlativesUse when scoping a complex strategy or world-building architecture and you need to separate negotiable design…From Lives of Eminent Philosophers