Don Quixote
by Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra
6 cardsCervantes, 1605/1615 (Ormsby 1885 translation, public domain): the reality-proof mind. How a story survives every collision with fact, and how it becomes real once other people start investing in it.
Blame the enchanter, never the story
Quixote charges thirty windmills believing they are giants. His lance shatters, horse and rider go rolling over the plain. Sancho says the obvious: they were only windmills. Quixote's answer: 'that same sage Friston who carried off my study and books, has turned these giants into mills in order to rob me of the glory of vanquishing them.' The defeat is real. The story survives by inventing a hostile magician who altered reality at the last moment.
— In our words · Source: Don Quixote (Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra)
Name it and it becomes the thing
A barber rides by on a grey ass, wearing a brass basin on his head against the rain. Quixote sees 'a knight on a dappled grey steed, who has upon his head a helmet of gold.' Sancho sees a man on an ass with something shiny on his head. Quixote declares: 'Well, that is the helmet of Mambrino.' From that instant the basin IS the helmet, and Sancho will call it so for the rest of the book. The narrator's verdict: 'everything he saw he made to fall in with his crazy chivalry and ill-errant notions.'
— In our words · Source: Don Quixote (Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra)
The frame overrides the input
Two flocks of sheep raise dust on the plain. Quixote announces the armies of the emperor Alifanfaron, 'lord of the great isle of Trapobana,' and his enemy Pentapolin of the Bare Arm, complete with backstories, a love affair, and a religious war. Sancho sees sheep. Earlier, an inn becomes a castle with the same effortlessness (Part 1, ch. 16: 'the inn which he took to be a castle'). The eyes deliver raw input; the frame decides what was seen. The frame wins every time.
— In our words · Source: Don Quixote (Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra)
Proximity converts the skeptic
Sancho begins as the grounded man: 'Look, your worship, what we see there are not giants but windmills.' By Part 2 he kneels before the Duchess and delivers a full courtly embassy: 'that knight that you see there, the Knight of the Lions by name, is my master... may it please your highness to give him leave that, with your permission, approbation, and consent, he may come and carry out his wishes.' The Duchess marvels that he delivered it 'with all the formalities such messages require.' The skeptic now speaks fluent delusion.
— In our words · Source: Don Quixote (Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra)
Once public, your story gets staged back at you
The Duke and Duchess have read Part 1. When the real Quixote arrives, 'from it were aware of Don Quixote's crazy turn, they awaited him with the greatest delight and anxiety to make his acquaintance, meaning to fall in with his humour and agree with everything he said, and, so long as he stayed with them, to treat him as a knight-errant.' They stage elaborate pranks inside his fantasies for their own amusement. His story, once published, becomes a script other people perform, for their ends, not his.
— In our words · Source: Don Quixote (Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra)
The world needs the story more than the teller
Dying, Quixote renounces everything: 'I am no longer Don Quixote of La Mancha, but Alonso Quixano... Now I see through their absurdities and deceptions.' His friends do not celebrate his recovery. Samson Carrasco begs: 'Now that we have intelligence of the lady Dulcinea being disenchanted, are you taking this line... Hush, for heaven's sake, be rational and let's have no more nonsense.' They plead with the sane man to go back to being mad. The delusion has outgrown its host; the audience needs it now.
— In our words · Source: Don Quixote (Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra)