Idea Ripper // ArchiveCards: 1555 [Live] | Updated: 2026-10-14
Card #c519IR // #c519Synthesis

"The logical man is always self-righteous and therefore inhuman and therefore wrong, while the reasonable man suspects that perhaps he is wrong and is therefore always right." Logic deprived of common sense becomes inhuman: it pushes every theory doggedly to its absurd conclusion and erects the state, the class, or the system into a god that swallows the individual. Reasonableness — "humanized thinking" — rounds out ideas and tones down their angularities. In human affairs the illogical course is often the convincing one: the postscript that contradicts the letter, the pardon that voids the argument, the unanswerable case answered with compassion.

— In our words · Source: The Importance of Living (Lin Yutang)

[Use when]

An argument is airtight and everyone is still miserable — the logic isn't wrong, it's inhuman; look for the reasonable postscript.

[Why it matters]

Most modern disputes are fought with flawless logic on both sides and zero reasonableness — which is why they never end. The mechanism Lin names: certainty is the tell. The person who is entirely sure is the person the argument has captured; the person with a flash of doubt in the postscript is the one still thinking. Fanaticism, left or right, is not a doctrine problem — it's a reasonableness deficit.

More from The Importance of Living

#c510"Reality + Dreams + Humor = Wisdom" — Lin's calculus. Dreams (imagination, aspiration, idealism) are the fuel of life; humor is the…A cause, a pitch, or your own enthusiasm starts feeling airtight — look for the missing term before it costs… #c511"Human dignity must be associated with the idea of a scamp and not with that of an obedient, disciplined and regimented soldier." Man is…You catch yourself (or your organization) rewarding obedience and discipline while quietly punishing… #c512"Any good practical philosophy must start out with the recognition of our having a body." Lin calls this reasonable naturalism: passions…A philosophy, diet, or productivity doctrine asks you to declare war on your own body — try tuning the…